10 Comments

A few pointers. When the movie Hamid showed religious groups trying to recruit boys 7 - 8 years old, that was not contested, just because the movie presented the perspective of poor kashmiri Muslims harassed by the armed forces.

Whataboutery is usually a tool of the right wing, but here we see the tables turned, thanks to Agnihotri. Everybody is trying to trivialize the plight of the pandits using other massacres, riots or even just the number of deaths as a comparison. It allows the right wing to now return the liberal voices the same argument is two wrongs not making a right. All the pandits need for an emotional closure on this issue is an acknowledgement without any "if" or "but" in the sentence.

The JNU cabal's depiction is not unfounded. Prof Nivedita Menon has justified armed resistance and calls for Azadi in Kashmir, has declared India an illegal occupier of Kashmir without so much as mentioning that Pakistan and China were also there. She has sloganeered defending Afzal Guru. Leftist activists and journalists tried to "save" Yasin Malik's life and image. Madhu Kishwar realised the futility of this in due time.

Expand full comment

Movies on Gujarat Riots are true and heart wrenching...and movie on Kashmiri pandits massacre is filled with lies and propaganda ?? Don't you ever feel shame about your existence? A low budget movie showing 50% of truth has shaken your wrong doings! Of all the freebies which your community has enjoyed in this country for more than 70 years by doing nothing and brilliantly played victim card has not enough for you? what you want to swallow whole Hindu population in your propaganda just like your ancestors done??

Expand full comment

Writer is unconsciously biased towards his own community and hurt by truth represented in film.. my empathy is with writer, get well soon..

Expand full comment

It is so convenient point out what is wrong in the film and overlook the bigger picture. Why it is so difficult to just feel sorry of what happened to Kashmiri pandits and feel apologetic on behalf of those whose did all these. But no people like you have only one motive to oppose even if something is true. This behaviour of your makes the talk true that you all are being paid to do so.

Expand full comment

Truth hurts, isn't it?

Expand full comment

So what proof do you have that its a lie? If you are so sure add the proofs? So all the interview of bitta karate is fake? Dont be delusional. Start to accept the fact

Expand full comment

I feel bad for non-muslims who read such posts, dripped in half truths, beautiful story lines, cute 'Infidel killer' Sufi saints and try to engage with or question these people. Best thing you can do is to follow some international ex-muslim channel, understand Islam, its scriptures and history. Every thing would be crystal clear to you. What they have been doing, what this religion teaches. As far as wasting time with the people such as the writer is concerned, they know very well, about what Islam is and what is its purpose, what all things it sactions against 'non-believers' . They aren't some innocent folks trying to tell you the truth. So save your time. All these honey dripped stories are written to save Islam. As long as Islam is alive, there would be terrorism, bullying, hate towards non-believers. That's what is teaches. Muslims aren't going to let go of such a wonderful tool.

Expand full comment

Encashment and political mileage are the only 2 agendas of this movie by presenting a bouquet of lies which actually belittles the pain and suffering of whole kashmiri community.

Expand full comment

Who Was Sikander Butshikan ? if Islam was only spread by love and sufism

Expand full comment

Hmm. . 200+ crores for a movie full of lies, right?

Expand full comment